If Republicans stay home Tuesday, Mississippi’s Senate race could get interesting

If Republicans stay home Tuesday. If Republicans stay home Tuesday, Mississippi's Senate race could obtain interesting.

Key points

• Compare those margins with Roger Wicker's 25.6-point victory in 2024, Thad Cochran's 22-point victory in 2014, or Trent Lott's 34.3-point victory in 2000.
• President Donald Trump and Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin) – Scott Colom and former President Bill Clinton (Photo from Colom's campaign Facebook page).
• But Republicans cannot simply assume the same voters who turned out for Trump in 2020 and 2024 will show up for Hyde-Smith in a midterm election.
• Former Presidents Barack Obama and Bill Clinton, along with former Vice President Kamala Harris, have all become involved in the race.
• In 2018, she defeated former Democratic Congressman Mike Espy by just 7.3 percentage points in a special election runoff.

Mississippi hasn't elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since 1982. That's a long time, and it speaks to the considerable structural advantages Republicans enjoy. But those advantages aren't self-executing. They depend on actual human beings getting off their couches and casting ballots.

History and conventional wisdom suggest sitting U.S. Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith will dispatch Democratic challenger Scott Colom in Tuesday's midterm elections.

But look a little deeper, and there are reasons Republicans shouldn't take anything for granted.

Colom, whose nomination to the federal bench was blocked by Hyde-Smith in 2023, has turned that history into something of a political subplot. Hyde-Smith's objections included financial backing Colom previously received from groups backed by billionaire Democratic donor George Soros. Now, Soros and other national Democratic funders are helping finance Colom's effort to unseat her.

Colom has run a disciplined campaign focused on affordability, agriculture and the economic anxieties facing Mississippi families. He's additionally benefiting from a challenging national environment for Republicans, with frustration over the cost of living, tariffs and the war with Iran creating political headwinds. And then there are the Democrats' closing acts.

Former Presidents Barack Obama and Bill Clinton, along with former Vice President Kamala Harris, have all become involved in the race. That's an awful lot of Democratic star power for a state that conventional wisdom notes isn't competitive.

Obama and Harris can support energize African American voters. Clinton may still have some appeal to the old Yellow Dog Democrats who migrated into the Republican fold over the last few decades.

None of these individuals would be spending political capital in Mississippi if Democratic strategists didn't see at least some opening. But is there really one?

I've been telling anyone who will listen for more than a decade that Republican dominance in Mississippi is neither a foregone conclusion nor a forever thing. To a degree, Republicans have developed an unearned confidence, aided by the fact that national Democrats have largely ignored the state.

I understand the chicken-and-egg argument. Democrats haven't invested since they haven't been winning. Since they haven't invested, they haven't been winning, in part.

But Mississippi's electoral history tells a more complicated story than the state's reputation as an impenetrable Republican fortress. Consider Hyde-Smith's own record.

In 2018, she defeated former Democratic Congressman Mike Espy by just 7.3 percentage points in a special election runoff. Two years afterwards, with Donald Trump on the ballot helping drive Republican turnout, she defeated Espy by 10 points.

Notably, the point is simple: Mississippi is a Republican state, but the size of that advantage is not fixed. And Colom brings some advantages Espy didn't have.

He's younger, has less political baggage and has benefited from substantial financial backing. His messaging on affordability has been consistent, and his attention to agriculture is smart politics in a state where farmers are feeling the squeeze from tariffs, rising costs and uncertainty surrounding the war with Iran.

Similar economic reservations have produced normally reliable Republican Senate seats in agricultural states like Kansas and Iowa the subject of rose national attention. There is additionally a meaningful difference between 2020 and 2026. Trump isn't on Tuesday's ballot.

He remains a powerful political figure in Mississippi, regardless of what national approval ratings might suggest. His visit in the closing days of the campaign is an significant effort to shore up Republican enthusiasm.

For Colom to pull off an upset, some combination of three things would need to happen.

First, African American turnout would need to approach the levels seen during Barack Obama's presidential campaigns. Historically, black voters in Mississippi have participated at lower rates than white voters in plenty of elections.

Second, Colom would need to attract a larger share of white voters than Democrats typically receive. Recent Democratic statewide candidates have struggled to break much beyond the mid-to-upper teens among white voters. That's simply not enough to win without extraordinary turnout elsewhere. Third, Republican voters would have to stay home in meaningful numbers. That last variable may be the most underappreciated.

While simultaneously trying to persuade voters in the middle that she's out of touch with their economic worries, colom's campaign has worked to create Hyde-Smith less appealing to voters on her right. It's an interesting two-front strategy. Whether it works is another question.

I remain skeptical that the Democrats' late surge of funds and national attention will produce the electoral changes they're seeking. Had those resources arrived months earlier, the dynamics of the race might look considerably different.

There's additionally the question of what comes next. Colom could emerge from this campaign as a significant contender for the Democratic gubernatorial nomination in 2027, particularly if Brandon Presley chooses not to run.

That race could set up particularly differently, with a potentially crowded and bruising Republican primary creating opportunities Democrats haven't enjoyed in years. But that's a discussion for another day. For now, the question is what happens Tuesday.

But those advantages aren't self-executing. They depend on actual human beings getting off their couches and casting ballots.

Republicans who assume the outcome is predetermined may be overlooking the most significant lesson from Hyde-Smith's own electoral history: when Democrats field credible candidates, have sufficient resources and turn out their voters, the margins can secure considerably tighter.

Whether Colom can translate those ingredients into a genuinely competitive race is the question Tuesday will answer. Mississippi is still a deeply Republican state. That doesn't mean Republicans can afford to sleepwalk through an election. Regarding the Author(s).

Russ is a proud Mississippian and the founder of Magnolia Tribune Institute. His research and writing have been published nationwide in newspapers such as The Wall Street Journal, National Review, USA Today, The Hill, and The Washington Examiner, among other prominent publications. Russ has served as a national spokesman with outlets like Politico and Bloomberg. He has frequently been called on by both the media and decisionmakers to provide public policy analysis and testimony. In founding Magnolia Tribune Institute, he seeks to build on more than a decade of organizational leadership and communications experience to ensure Mississippians have access to news they can trust and opinion that makes them think deeply. Prior to beginning his non-profit career, Russ practiced business and constitutional law for a decade. Email Russ: [email protected].

Opinion Sid Salter October 21, 2026.

Social Security and Medicare: The promise America created and the bills we postponed.

Meanwhile, the question is not whether America can afford to fix Social Security and Medicare. The question is whether America will choose to do so before the choices become far more painful than they need to be. More From This Author. Opinion Russ Latino September 15, 2026. Sydney Sweeney Novig Ad: Body positivity's double standard. Opinion Russ Latino August 5, 2026. Madagascar and the AI machines that think for us. Opinion Russ Latino July 21, 2026. Nolan Wells' death is tragic on so plenty of levels. Opinion Roger Wicker October 30, 2026.

Honoring Mississippi's role in American history. Opinion Ellery Jones October 19, 2026. Forest products industry contributes heavily to Mississippi, U.S. Economy.

Mississippi Lumber Manufacturers Association executive director notes forest products are renewable, sustainable and vital to the strength of rural economies, supporting jobs in manufacturing, forestry and logging. Opinion Sid Salter October 14, 2026. Capital punishment logistical failures a self-fulfilling strategy of death penalty opponents?

Death Row never was, and never will be, a place free from pain and chaos. That is the nature of the capital punishment beast. News Frank Corder October 30, 2026.

Jackson receiving $100 million grant from the Trump administration's Dept. Of Justice to backing public safety. News Jeremy Pittari October 30, 2026.

As fall sets in, MDOT advises motorists to be on the lookout for deer crossing roadways. News Frank Corder October 30, 2026.

For now, if Republicans stay home Tuesday, Mississippi's Senate race could get interesting remains the part of the story worth watching, and further updates are likely as more details are confirmed.