High school football playoffs have a problem: Why winning isn’t always enough

High school football playoffs have a difficulty: Why winning isn't always enough.

SportsNews Info Wire6 min read
High school football playoffs have a problem: Why winning isn't always enough

High school football playoffs have a difficulty: Why winning isn't always enough.

Article outline

  1. What happened
  2. The details
  3. What comes next
  4. A closer look
  5. More on the story
  6. The bottom line

Key points

  • In Ocala, Florida, Forest High School was left out of the playoffs after securing an 8-2 record – its first eight-win season in almost two decades.
  • Strength of schedule was a major factor in the rankings, and head-to-head wins held less weight, according to MaxPreps Senior Director of Content Steve Montoya.
  • While USA TODAY Sports did not receive a response from Coosa head coach Jason Howard, chamblee head coach Bob Swank declined to comment on his team's experience.
  • Florida and Arizona aren't the only teams who adopted a new ranking system this season, Georgia introduced a new formula call the Post Season Rankings (PSR).
  • "Are we telling people that it's okay to pump your schedule up with a bunch of top-ranked teams and go 2-8, " head coach Sean Freeman questioned.

High school football playoff selections are always bound to spark controversy. But this year, the debate is bigger than which teams are in and out.

Nationwide, teams are beginning to question the process to determine their postseason fate.

That's since a number of states switched their playoff ranking formats this season, creating new challenges for teams.

Florida and Arizona are two states who opted to employ the MaxPreps rankings to produce their postseason brackets. This was a decision that both school boards voted on ahead of the season, but the ranking system rapidly created controversy.

In Ocala, Florida, Forest High School was left out of the playoffs after securing an 8-2 record – its first eight-win season in almost two decades. Instead, Oakleaf (5-5), a team that Forest beat 21-7 in the regular season, secured the final spot in the Class 5A bracket.

"It's about the kids, " Forest head coach John Brantley informed USA TODAY Sports. "My kids were extremely disappointed when it came out and we weren't being involved in the playoffs."

Meanwhile, the biggest frustration for Brantley was the lack of transparency surrounding the ranking calculations.

"The bottom line is nobody knows what the criteria is, " remarked Brantley. "I mean that's the thing that's got everybody kind of up in arms that probably didn't get a fair shake from the rankings." It's not all regarding winning.

"Scheduling is key in the process, " he remarked on the FHSAA bracket release show. "That strength of schedule comes into play."

In Arizona, Tempe High School experienced a similar result. The Buffaloes additionally finished their season 8-2, but finished four spots shy of the Class 4A playoffs.

"Are we telling people that it's okay to pump your schedule up with a bunch of top-ranked teams and go 2-8, " head coach Sean Freeman questioned. "Or is it, 'Hey, this team has six wins or seven wins, they deserve a spot in the playoffs?'".

When both teams' opponents cancelled their scheduled games, tempe even volunteered to play Scottsdale Chaparral, a Class 5A team. Although the Buffaloes lost 57-0, Freeman was informed playing a team in a higher classification could earn them further points in the rankings.

Nevertheless, Chaparral went on to finish its season 5-5. It didn't assist Tempe's case.

"The rating, a lot of times, is built based off of what your opponents are doing, " Montoya remarked.

MaxPreps remarked it is taking feedback from both states into consideration to improve the formula.

"We like all this feedback, even if it's negative, because it helps us get better, " Montoya remarked. Is there a clear-cut solution?

Freeman is already thinking of ways he can create a more appealing schedule for the ranking system next season.

"Me and my assistant coach are already sitting here plotting and planning, " Freeman remarked. "We've obtained to load up our first five games with top-tier teams that are going to be teams that are going to continue winning throughout the season. That's the way the formula's going."

Freeman, nevertheless, observed that resources play a significant role in scheduling games outside of your region.

"That also plays a huge toll, " he remarked. "Now you're talking about nutrition for your kids, you're talking about sleeping schedules and all that to get to games that are maybe an hour or two away from where you're at in your city."

Brantley created a similar argument for his Florida program, saying the new system could force teams to travel on a weekly basis to improve their postseason chances.

"To get in the playoffs you've got to address these situations – it may involve me having to go 120 miles to play a better team to have an opportunity to go play in the playoffs, " Brantley remarked. "We just don't have the money and the resources to do that on a regular weekly basis."

Under the new format, the top 32 teams in each classification qualified for the playoffs, rather than automatically awarding postseason spots to the top four teams in each region.

In practice, the rankings employ a formula that additionally values a team's strength of schedule. That's why Buford, who is ranked No. 3 in the USA TODAY Sports Super 25 national rankings, earned the No. 9 seed in the Class 7A playoffs despite finishing the season with a perfect 10-0 record.

Notably, the new system additionally created confusion for a pair of other teams.

In Class 6A and 2A, Chamblee High School and Coosa High School were originally informed that their teams had created the postseason, but received emails just three hours afterwards stating that updated scores pushed them out of the bracket.

Chamblee, which finished the season 6-4 was pushed out by Veterans. It finished their season 4-6.

There is no perfect formula to determine rankings, and no playoff system is going to satisfy every team.

At the end of the day, nevertheless, coaches simply want more of a say in the process.

"The consensus that I'm getting from a lot of the coaches is that there needs to be a more coaches-driven, athlete-record-driven type of committee where all coaches have a say, " Freeman remarked. "I don't feel that all of us have a say in the system." Share your feedback to support improve our site!

Taken together, the developments around high school football playoffs have a problem: Why winning isnt always enough point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *