Ukraine, Russia race to build military satellite networks as war rages on

Kyiv, Ukraine - Looking like a tiny desktop tower with wing-like solar panels, the Obria Nano satellite is a small step that could herald a giant leap for Ukraine's military.

WorldNews Info Wire7 min read
Ukraine, Russia race to build military satellite networks as war rages on

Kyiv, Ukraine – Looking like a tiny desktop tower with wing-like solar panels, the Obria Nano satellite is a small step that could herald a giant leap for Ukraine's military.

Article outline

  1. What happened
  2. Official response
  3. Why it matters
  4. Background
  5. What comes next
  6. The bottom line

Key points

  • Bureau 1440, a Kremlin-controlled space firm that runs the Rassvet system, aims to have 900 satellites in orbit by 2035.
  • OneWeb, operated by the French Eutelsat firm, has up to 650 satellites that orbit the Earth at 1, 200 kilometres (746 miles).
  • Kyiv's attempts to find an alternative to Starlink followed the October 14-24 speed limits for Ukrainian drones imposed without prior warning by Starlink and Starshield.
  • The US-based Iridium has 66 satellites flying at regarding 800km (497 miles) above Earth.
  • But in late 2022, Musk refused to activate Starlink coverage in Russia-occupied areas, slowing down or stopping Ukraine's successful counteroffensive.

Introduced by Himera, a Ukrainian business known for ergonomic military radios, and GomSpace, a Danish small-satellite manufacturer, the first Obria Nano could eventually grow into Kyiv's own constellation of military satellites, its creators hope.

In practice, the nanosatellite marks Ukraine's "first historical step toward establishing resilient and sovereign satellite communications capabilities, " the firm stated on October 27, almost four weeks after the Obria Nano had reached orbit.

In mid-October, Kyiv additionally signed up two Finnish businesses, the Nokia telecoms giant and the ICEYE space startup that owns a "self-illuminating" radar technology for obtaining high-resolution satellite imagery in any weather, to look into developing a network of military satellites.

Kyiv's efforts are rooted in one concern – the almost total dependence of Ukraine's military communications on SpaceX, Elon Musk's satellite communications giant that operates Starlink, a constellation of more than 10, 000 low-orbit satellites.

On Thursday, the speeds of Starlink and Starshield, its military component operated by the Pentagon, were limited for Ukraine, leading to "significant disruptions" of their operation along the front line, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy remarked. Before this, Starlink was additionally disrupted last month.

Kyiv realises that "it's possible to create an absolutely new system, but it will take several years, " Anatoly Zak, a US-based space expert, informed Al Jazeera. "In the nearest year or two, Starlink and Starshield are absolutely necessary."

Since 2022, Ukraine developed a love-and-hate relationship with Musk, his volatility, shifting loyalties and political demands.

"Musk's mood swings play a significant role, " Volodymyr Fesenko, head of the Kyiv-based Penta think tank, informed Al Jazeera. "There were times when Musk helped Ukraine, and times of very negative reactions."

Ukrainians hailed Musk's decision to provide Starlink services and modems to Ukraine free of charge. The military, hospitals and administration agencies operating critical infrastructure swiftly created a backbone of their communications.

According to The world's wealthiest man additionally, kyiv should remain "politically neutral" going forward, officially cede Crimea to Moscow and conduct United Nations-supervised referendums on Russia-occupied territories.

"If you want to understand what Russia has done here, come to Ukraine and you will see it all for yourself, " Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy remarked in response. "And then you will tell me how to end this war, who started it and when it can be ended."

Meanwhile, Russia has reportedly smuggled thousands of Starlink terminals and applied them for comms and drone attacks. This February, Musk put an end to the practice by allowing only certified modems to operate in Ukraine.

Drones and drone interceptors moving faster than 60km/h (37mph) lost signal and could no longer reach their targets.

Musk accused the Pentagon of limiting the speed and admitted that the decision was his only after The Wall Street Journal documented that Musk had personally authorised the slowdown.

Both Musk and Kyiv realise that Starlink and Starshield are the Ukrainian military's survival tool.

When it comes to his highly publicised position towards Ukraine, Musk has to balance his own emotional outbursts and the interests of SpaceX, the crown jewel of his business empire that comprises two-fifths of his net worth, analyst Fesenko remarked.

"If he tries to throw Ukraine under the bus, it may work as very negative advertising for his business, including the Starlink system, " Fesenko remarked. Russia's bid to create military satellites.

Another factor is Russian President Vladimir Putin's calculated flattery towards Musk – on October 28, he called him a "real genius".

"Putin apparently wants to use the methods he's used towards Trump – flattery, unlimited flattery, " Fesenko remarked.

Putin mentioned Musk while talking regarding Russia's attempts to create its own version of Starlink.

"We are in close contact with our American partners – including Mr Musk – because it's very important, in orbit, not to get in each other's way and to maintain a certain level of discipline and order, " Putin remarked. The attempts have not been particularly successful so far.

Notably, the military satellites for the upcoming Rassvet (Dawn) constellation turned out to be Qianfan satellites. It are similar to first-generation Starlink satellites and manufactured in China.

In August, the Institute for the Study of War, an international military think tank, asserted that more than a third of Rassvet satellites failed to reach "sustainable operational altitudes".

By early November, Moscow lost two of the 32 Rassvet 3 satellites introduced previously seven months.

For context, the second satellite that burned in the Earth's atmosphere on November 1, failed to launch its propulsion to correct its position, according to The Defence Express, a Ukrainian military publication.

Ukraine can additionally try negotiating a switch to Starlink's rivals, but they are smaller and less effective.

In practice, the US-based Iridium has 66 satellites flying at regarding 800km (497 miles) above Earth.

OneWeb, operated by the French Eutelsat firm, has up to 650 satellites that orbit the Earth at 1, 200 kilometres (746 miles). But it is not authorised to be applied for military drone strikes.

For context, an average terminal in Ukraine sees five dozen Starlink satellites simultaneously – and only 11 OneWeb satellites. A light, compact Starlink terminal costs up to $500; a much heavier and bulkier OneWeb one costs $9, 000.

According to Pavel Luzin, a space and military analyst with the Jamestown Foundation, a think tank in Washington, DC, Kyiv has two options to obtain its own satellites.

It could work towards heavy and pricey satellites in geosynchronous orbit – or Earth-centred – that could serve for up to 20 years and cover all of Ukraine's military needs.

Or option two is a focus on launching a system of hundreds of cheaper low-orbit satellites that will need propulsion engines to maintain position, but they will eventually fall down since of contact with the upper atmosphere, and will constantly need to be replaced, he stated.

Kyiv can additionally apply much cheaper alternatives such as stratostats or stratospheric drones that serve as "quasi-satellites, " he informed Al Jazeera.

Meanwhile, a satellite fleet necessary to provide coordinates to long-range drones makes each drone strike pricier, and AI-driven drones that can be "taught" to recognise their targets could bring the cost down – and produce the satellites unnecessary.

Since they do not need satellite connection but can cause damage equal to the boom from a number of drones that have gotten through Russia's air defence system, he noted, the development of ballistic missiles is another alternative.

"Such decisions are made with all calculations considered, not because Starlink – that depends on current political trends in Washington – needs to be replaced with an alternative, " Luzin remarked.

Taken together, the developments around ukraine, Russia race to build military satellite networks as war rages on point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *