Russia's mega-rich are already imagining a future after Putin
ByVitaly Shevchenko Chief Analyst, BBC Monitoring.
ByVitaly Shevchenko Chief Analyst, BBC Monitoring.
Article outline
- What happened
- The key numbers
- Official response
- What comes next
- Background
- The bottom line
Key points
- Hours after launching his full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022, Vladimir Putin gathered Russia's richest men in the Kremlin's cavernous Yekaterininsky Hall.
- Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has kept Russia's rich businessmen in line with a ruthless policy of carrot and stick.
- This era of the "wild 1990s" was when the so-called "new Russians" burst onto the scene.
- But almost immediately after Putin was first elected as president in 2000, he subjugated the oligarchs.
- And then there's the third option: tycoons re-assert their power and Russia returns to something resembling a 1990s-style system of oligarchy.
More than three dozen of them sat huddled along a wall, wearing face masks since of the Covid pandemic. One Russian newspaper reporter described them as "pale and sleep-deprived". On entering, Putin sat down at the opposite side of the hall, creating a vast space between him and the businessmen. As usual, he was wearing no mask.
Using his typically coded language, he remarked he anticipated them to backing the war.
"I would like to call on you to show understanding of what is going on, " he remarked, "and work together with the government to find the tools which would support production, the economy, jobs."
In the Kremlin-published video of the session, none of the invited billionaires stated a word.
That silence has become a feature of the Russian super-rich. Over the decades of Putin's rule, they have learnt that the cost of piping up could be high. In 2003, oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Russia's richest man at the time. This person was funding a number of opposition groups, accused Putin of presiding over rampant corruption. He spent the next 10 years behind bars, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement – a warning to other would-be critics. He denied the charges.
And even if any of the tycoons objected to the war, they have tended to keep their thoughts to themselves.
But even in that silence, there are murmurings: some members of Russia's once-mighty business elite seem to be imagining a Russia after Putin. When the oligarchs enjoyed the fruits of power – or even if a healthier politics may take root, they are wondering if, once the president has left office or died, the country might look more like it did in the 1990s.
In practice, the journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, a prominent Kremlin-watcher at The Economist newspaper who lately spent hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men, states he feels that a "historic, political shift is happening" in terms of how the ultra-rich view the future of the country.
For context, the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 offered birth to a new, powerful force on the domestic scene: residents who took advantage of the end of communism and became extraordinarily rich, and then wanted to control politicians for their own benefit. They were dubbed "the oligarchs", from Ancient Greek for the "few who rule". They had funds, which back then meant power.
This era of the "wild 1990s" was when the so-called "new Russians" burst onto the scene. Massive state businesses came up for grabs, and men with the right connections became millionaires – even billionaires – almost overnight. Corruption was rife, cronyism rampant, and contract killings frequent.
But almost immediately after Putin was first elected as president in 2000, he subjugated the oligarchs. He had little interest in sharing power with anyone else. He could afford to stand up to the billionaires since Russia's economy was getting back on its feet, and the central administration was getting stronger.
Bill Browder, a financier who applied to be the biggest foreign investor in Russia, and was banned from the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, states the Russian tycoons cowered and wilted in front of Putin – for example at the Davos economic forum, in the pre-war years when they were still welcomed there.
"I can remember seeing oligarchs walking around like they own the place, the most arrogant and self-confident individuals. And then Putin indicated up, and it was just remarkable to see how these supposedly alpha-male-on-steroids individuals turned into absolutely subordinate, almost desperate schoolchildren, " he tells the BBC.
Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has kept Russia's rich businessmen in line with a ruthless policy of carrot and stick. While loyalists have been rewarded with lavish administration war contracts: today there are more Russian billionaires than ever (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine), critics of the war have seen their assets seized. Their collective wealth has reached a new high of almost $700bn (£525bn).
But even for those tycoons who have stayed loyal and been rewarded, all of that funds doesn't seem to be making them happy. Some are growing restless. Autocracy, oligarchy or democracy?
Their billions do not go as far as they applied to: domestically, they cannot purchase much political influence.
"They have no cards, they have no game, " exiled politician and analyst Dmitry Nekrasov notes. "They're rich because they've got something to do with Putin, not the other way round."
And outside of Russia, they are ostracised since of the Western sanctions imposed on Russia after its full-scale invasion.
"They're treated like low-level criminals. They can't fly their private jets. Their yachts can't park in all the best harbours in Europe. It must be particularly awful and humiliating for them, " states Browder, the avowed Putin critic.
And so, quietly, some of their minds are turning to what happens after Putin leaves the scene. That's what I'm informed by well-placed analysts. This person are immersed in the world of these tycoons.
There's no immediate prospect of the president's departure, and there's no reason to think he's in bad health. But Putin, who turned 74 last month, has served in the Kremlin for a quarter of a century; individuals in Moscow know that his exit will come one day. When his constitutional term technically ends, Putin replied: "Only God knows if we have enough health.", when asked by Reuters last year if he intends to serve until 2036.
If Putin resigned or died in office, the prime minister, Mikhail Mishustin, would take over. But Mishustin has not exhibited any presidential ambitions (that's probably a key reason he was appointed). That would create something of a power vacuum.
In that scenario, Russia-watchers I have spoken with envisage a few potential scenarios.
Some in the West, and no doubt within Russia, hope that democracy might flourish in a post-Putin Russia, with administration led by the residents, rather than by a new cadre of oligarchs or a single autocrat. But this seems like the least probable path, analysts say. Key democratic institutions have been eroded or destroyed over Putin's rule. "Russia is so used to violence, it has grown unaccustomed to standard democratic procedures, " notes Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst.
Another path is more autocracy. A different figure could replace Putin and continue his culture of repression. But Prokopenko thinks this wouldn't be another strongman dictatorship – at least not right away. These things take time, she notes: at first, Putin's successor would be weaker than him, with fewer resources.
And then there's the third option: tycoons re-assert their power and Russia returns to something resembling a 1990s-style system of oligarchy. Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician who now lives in exile, notes under this scenario, the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite clans in alliance with business interests.
This last option, of course, is the one that plenty of tycoons want. "They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game, " notes Prokopenko, who has spent a lot of time speaking to Russia's richest residents.
Though their power has been seriously curtailed since the 1990s, it's still worth listening to the tycoons: given their immense wealth, it seems probable that sooner or afterwards they will try to re-assert their political influence.
Already, some are "trying to be friends with the right sort of security officials or ministers", notes Nekrasov, the exiled politician. But he notes any further steps are "too dangerous to take".
He notes the behaviour of the tycoons in coming years will depend in part on their finances. Those who have lots of liquid cash will be more confident to "play political games" and jockey for position, preparing for a post-Putin country. But those whose wealth is dependent on state contracts or administration goodwill will feel too afraid, in case they lose everything, he states.
Prokopenko notes there's already been a shift in how the businessmen talk concerning Putin. They applied to nickname him "Nachalnik" (which translates as "boss"), as well as "Perviy" ("first"), or by his initials "VV" – all nicknames that convey a degree of respect. Now they call him "Ded", with what Prokopenko calls "a pinch of contempt". "Ded" translates as "oldie" or "granddad" – a much less reverent name.
Some rich Russians are pining after a "return of politics into people's lives", she notes, with less repression, more open speech, and healthier competition between parties and politicians.
But right now, she notes, they are too afraid to produce that happen due to Russia's stifling atmosphere. Since he thought it would produce digital eavesdropping more tough for secret police, prokopenko interviewed one tycoon who physically sat on his phone during the whole conversation. "I thought that it's an absolutely Stalinistic type of fear. It's absolutely irrational, " she notes.
In practice, an interesting clue for what tycoons might want from a post-Putin future came from Andrey Melnichenko. This person is known as the world's fertiliser king and is at present Russia's eighth richest man.
Earlier this year, he surprised observers by giving an interview to The Economist – a rare thing for a rich Russian to do, especially to a publication from a country the Kremlin considers unfriendly. They additionally published an essay written by him.
In parts of the interview, Melnichenko repeated Kremlin talking points. He remarked that Ukraine is a battlefield between Russia and the West, and he thinks the West ignored Russia's security worries and threatens its sovereignty.
But then it obtained more interesting. Melnichenko did not call for Putin to go, but – and it's a major but – he argued for a change that would bring concerning an end to one-man rule in Russia. He remarked Russia needs to engage more with the world.
Prokopenko thinks the tycoon was trying to stir a public conversation. It was a "call on rich people like him to start talking", she notes.
For now, russia' s mega-rich are already imagining a future after Putin remains the part of the story worth watching, and further updates are likely as more details are confirmed.



