CFP committee’s Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce

CFP committee's Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce CFP committee bends the rules for Alabama, then insults us with the explanation.

GeneralNews Info Wire5 min read
CFP committee’s Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce

CFP committee's Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce CFP committee bends the rules for Alabama, then insults us with the explanation.

Article outline

  1. What happened
  2. Why it matters
  3. The details
  4. A closer look
  5. More on the story
  6. The bottom line

Key points

  • The first ridiculous argument for Alabama was a "major" win at Kentucky, and the win at Mississippi State when the Bulldogs were unbeaten in late September.
  • After losing to Arkansas and sustaining its fourth loss of the season, magically stayed in the CFP Top 25 at No, now we see why South Carolina.
  • One were the conference losses, and there were five games involved with Top 14 teams, so there was (poll) movement around Indiana, Yurachek remarked.
  • Maybe it's time to take a long, hard look at Alabama, the darling of the College Football Playoff poll.
  • Same with the obvious elephant in the room: Alabama's 16-point loss to Tennessee.

Which teams did the CFP selection committee rank too high or too low? Our college football insiders break down the most overrated and underrated teams in the latest College Football Playoff rankings.

In practice, the one program – more than any other – with a historical track record in the BCS and CFP era of annually receiving the benefit of the doubt.

Notably, the one program – more than any other – consistently and confoundingly protected by this year's CFP selection committee. Even with the committee's clear message last week to Indiana regarding opponent's results. More: Ohio State, Alabama headline CFP rankings winners and losers.

This week's poll, everyone, is a whopper of a benefit of the doubt.

In practice, a week ago, all six of Indiana's previously faced Major Ten opponents lost while the Hoosiers were on a bye week. Indiana then dropped from No. 4 to No. 9 in the CFP poll.

Fast forward to last weekend: five SEC teams previously beaten by Alabama lost, and the Tide – with an ugly win at Vanderbilt – stayed firm at No. 3.

If that blatant rules for thee and not for me nonsense doesn't create you want to scream SEC bias, listen to CFP selection committee chairman Hunter Yurachek explain this now weekly Alabama pretzel logic.

"Three things happened to Indiana. One were the conference losses, and there were five games involved with Top 14 teams, so there was (poll) movement around Indiana, " Yurachek remarked. "And Indiana had a bye and didn't have an opportunity to improve its resume."

If that doesn't create you want to ditch the selection committee system, Yurachek wasn't done. According to He then, alabama didn't move down, and the five opponent losses didn't have the same impact that it did on Indiana a week prior, as – and I can't believe I'm writing this – "the quality of strength of schedule those five teams had lost." What the hell does that even mean?

EMPTY WORDS: Curt Cignetti fires back at Indiana schedule critics. Too bad he's using blanks.

GIG'D AGAIN: Mike Elko talked tough. Now Texas A&M is irrelevant and he's begging for time.

It is here where I must readdress the reality that Yurachek is just the face of the committee as its chairman. But he's not sent out blind in front of ESPN cameras during the rankings show.

He has notes from the committee, and you better believe he was expecting the Indiana/Alabama comparison. And this is what that 13-member committee came up with?

Essentially, the committee just remarked Alabama didn't drop as it's Alabama. Frankly, I'd have been a lot happier if they just remarked that and secured it out in the open.

Same with the obvious elephant in the room: Alabama's 16-point loss to Tennessee. It last weekend whipped Texas A&M on the road – worse than Alabama did in Tuscaloosa – and dropped from No. 8 to No. 9. Yurachek: "The committee really values Tennessee." Hunter, babe, I don't think they do.

Just say we think Alabama's near win against Georgia in Tuscaloosa is the most significant game of the season, and it supersedes any other metric brought into the equation when evaluating the Tide. Just freaking admit it, already.

Stop dancing around these idiotic pretzel logic arguments, stripping more and more integrity from the selection committee process.

Notably, the first ridiculous argument for Alabama was a "major" win at Kentucky, and the win at Mississippi State when the Bulldogs were unbeaten in late September. Then Tennessee whipped Kentucky and Mississippi State tanked, and the CFP pretzel logic for Alabama moved to South Carolina and LSU.

Then South Carolina obtained humiliated by the worst team in the SEC, and LSU lost for the fourth time, and now it's the quality of the strength of schedule of the teams that lost. Whatever that means.

After losing to Arkansas and sustaining its fourth loss of the season, magically stayed in the CFP Top 25 at No, now we see why South Carolina. 21. And why Kentucky – which obviously was fool's gold – is still ranked in the Top 16 of the poll.

Who among us believes Kentucky is the No. 16 team in the nation? Much less worthy of the Top 25.

It's laughable what the CFP selection committee is doing, and they're blatantly doing it without hesitation. This week, Alabama plays FCS Chattanooga, and Tennessee plays LSU.

But LSU dropped out of the poll, so LSU won't be a significant win for the Vols – even though the Tigers were (and probable still are) a significant win for Alabama.

If the CFP selection committee doesn't care regarding head-to-head with Tennessee, why would it care concerning head-to-head with Georgia? It's good to be the CFP darling, everyone.

Matt Hayes is the senior national college football writer for USA TODAY Sports Network. Follow him on X at @MattHayesCFB. Listen to him daily, from 12-2 p.m., on 1010XL-Jacksonville. Share your feedback to support improve our site!

Taken together, the developments around CFP committee's Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *