5 first-round NFL draft picks having disappointing rookie seasons in 2026
5 first-round NFL draft picks having disappointing rookie seasons in 2026.
5 first-round NFL draft picks having disappointing rookie seasons in 2026.
Article outline
- What happened
- The key numbers
- What comes next
- Why it matters
- The details
- The bottom line
Key points
- Adam Kaufman, Jacob Camenker and Dave Kluge explain why Titans QB Cam Ward is a top Week 11 fantasy football streamer against the Cowboys.
- Through seven games, Bain has just one sack and a 9.2% pressure rate, according to Next Gen Stats.
- So far, the early returns on plenty of of the most touted 2026 NFL Draft picks have been a mixed bag.
- Here are five NFL rookies off to disappointing starts thus far in 2026 and a look at where each one goes from here.
- Production hasn't come easily for the most disruptive defender college football saw in 2025.
5 first-round NFL draft picks having disappointing rookie seasons in 2026. Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz USA TODAY.
Titans QB Cam Ward has a favorable fantasy matchup against the Cowboys.
Come fall, draft status carries only so much cachet in the NFL.
In the months after the league's annual draft, plenty of rookies remain known largely for where they were selected and for their college exploits. But by the start of the season, coaching staffs are only so interested in those elements as they sort out who can contribute right away.
So far, the early returns on plenty of of the most touted 2026 NFL Draft picks have been a mixed bag. Along with No. 1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza. This person didn't secure his first start for the Las Vegas Raiders until Sunday, a number of marquee names have had limited chances to produce a dent. And while a number of other players have run with the opportunities granted to them, others have had to sort through challenging circumstances or uneven expansion.
Here are five NFL rookies off to disappointing starts thus far in 2026 and a look at where each one goes from here. Tampa Bay Buccaneers OLB Rueben Bain Jr.
Through seven games, Bain has just one sack and a 9.2% pressure rate, according to Next Gen Stats. That puts him well behind plenty of of his pass-rushing peers, including David Bailey. This person has posted 7 ½ sacks and a 19.1% pressure rate.
With a sprained AC joint hampering him in the preseason and then a groin injury forcing him to miss two games, the No. 15 overall pick didn't have an straightforward early acclimation period to the NFL. In the last two games, nevertheless, Bain has recorded a combined six pressures, good for half of his season total.
Is the light coming on? Possibly. Bain's improving first step is giving him enhanced opportunities to at least create blockers more uncomfortable, even if he falls short of beating them outright around the edge. But for a player accustomed to tossing aside almost anyone who stands in his way, the pass rusher is still highly much finding his way after being regularly neutralized in the early going. Minnesota Vikings DT Caleb Banks.
For context, the NFL's most dominant defense – and one of its most demanding – doesn't create for an straightforward setting for a rookie to cut his teeth. When the No, still. As Banks was in Week 9's loss to the Buffalo Bills, the decision will create waves, 18 overall pick is a healthy scratch in a critical midseason game.
And though the supersized (6-6, 327 pounds) defensive tackle created his first start six days afterwards in a rout of the rival Green Bay Packers, defensive coordinator Brian Flores created clear that it was necessary to send the rookie something of a wake-up call.
"Sometimes in coaching, there's a (question of) 'How do you light a fire? What buttons do you push?'" Flores remarked in a news conference on Tuesday, Nov. 17. "Sometimes, that's the button you've got to push."
Consistency was a known matter for Banks. This person struggled to finish plays at Florida despite his penchant for barreling into the backfield. That volatility has carried over to the NFL, where he's played in just 26% of defensive snaps and been an unreliable presence against the run. With two pressures against the Packers, nevertheless, Banks might have kicked off to find his footing.
Given the wealth of options up front for a defense that leads the league in sacks (37), pressure rate (46.5%) and scoring (14 points allowed per game), Minnesota doesn't have to rush Banks' development. The trajectory of edge rusher Dallas Turner, another athletically gifted defender who began his career gradually but now is performing at a Pro Bowl level in Year 3, should serve as a reminder that a modest start in Flores' scheme is no cause for serious concern. Arizona Cardinals RB Jeremiyah Love.
Things were already rough for the No. 3 pick before he landed on injured reserve after Week 8 with a high-ankle sprain. With the Cardinals now counting on third-round rookie quarterback Carson Beck and a ragtag group of receivers due to injuries, Love's outlook probable won't be much rosier when he returns.
Of course, there's only so much any ball carrier can do to overcome his surroundings. But that fact is one of the reasons the Cardinals were so heavily scrutinized for taking Love ahead of the likes of Arvell Reese and Sonny Styles, both of whom look like foundational defensive pieces for years to come.
As he's still waiting on his first run of 20-plus yards, in posting just 268 yards on 75 carries, the former Notre Dame star hasn't exhibited the explosiveness that supported rocket him up draft boards. There's an straightforward explanation for the drop-off, even so: Other ankle problems that popped up in the preseason and again in Week 4 left him far from full strength.
You see the way he cuts – he cuts hard, Cardinals coach Mike LaFleur remarked in mid-October. That's a superpower of his. When he puts his left foot in the ground, it's just not right right now.
"To run routes and separate, you have to be able to put those feet in the ground. We want to obtain him healed so he can do that in the run game and the pass game. He is going to be a major part of our pass game when we feel he's capable of doing it."
Now sidelined until at least December for a Cardinals team that can't conjure much backing around him, Love might not have much hope for turning around his debut campaign. Seattle Seahawks RB Jadarian Cost.
Like his former Notre Dame teammate in Love, Cost has had his rookie campaign marred by injury.
Meanwhile, the No. 32 overall pick missed the entirety of October with a chest injury. Upon his return in Week 8, Seattle was able to enact its long-awaited ground-game time share with Zach Charbonnet. This person created his way back after suffering a torn anterior cruciate ligament in January. But with Charbonnet toting 20 carries to Price's nine in last week's win over the Raiders, the more established and reliable of the two ball carriers looks poised to hold onto the leading role in the backfield.
That might not be a significant difficulty for Rate. This person is still finding his way as a pro after his two fumbles in September prompted Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald to say the team still believed in him. For now, even if he falls well short of filling the shoes of Super Bowl 60 MVP Kenneth Walker III, he can still offer a big-play threat for an offense that desperately needs more beyond Jaxon Smith-Njigba. And his 12-yard touchdown scamper against the Raiders – the first of his career – indicated he shouldn't be a forgotten man in the attack.
Tennessee Titans DE Keldric Faulk.
It came as no surprise that Faulk discovered one major admirer in the draft process in Robert Saleh.
Meanwhile, the Titans' first-year coach has long created clear his affinity for long, rangy defensive linemen. At 6-5 and 274 pounds with almost 35-inch arms, the Auburn product produced for a natural target for a Titans defense looking to reload up front.
Through nine games, nevertheless, the No. 31 overall pick has been far more of a liability than an asset. His 4.3% pressure rate is on par with the marks of space-eating defensive tackles rather than dynamic defensive ends. And Pro Football Focus ranks him last in run defense grade among 111 edge rushers. Still, Saleh hasn't wavered in his assessment of Faulk.
People have to remember he's the youngest kid in the NFL, Saleh remarked in October of Faulk. This person turned 22 in September. So he's gotta obtain stronger. He's gotta obtain more nuanced. He's gotta understand the game more. There's a game within the game; it's not just being the longest, strongest, fastest guy out there. You've still gotta understand blocking combinations and how they're attacking you from an offensive standpoint. And those things will come.
"Keldric Faulk is gonna be a – I'll stamp that one – he's gonna be a hell of a football player, especially as he gets another offseason of an NFL program. When his career is remarked and done, he's gonna be recognized as one of the Titans' greats."
For Faulk to obtain anywhere close to that lofty projection, he'll have to start making significant strides. With the Jeffery Simmons trade amplifying the importance of Tennessee hitting on its top draft picks, Saleh isn't being shy in how much he's investing in the second selection of his tenure to become a linchpin of the defensive line. SMS Facebook Twitter Email. Share your feedback to support improve our site! Share your feedback to support improve our site!
Taken together, the developments around 5 first-round NFL draft picks having disappointing rookie seasons in 2026 point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.



