Greg McElroy, Jordan Rodgers baffled by CFP committee’s SEC criteria
Alabama over Texas? ESPN analyst blasts CFP committee's logic.
Alabama over Texas? ESPN analyst blasts CFP committee's logic.
Article outline
- What happened
- Why it matters
- What comes next
- Background
- The details
- The bottom line
Key points
- To Rodger's point, Texas is just ahead of Alabama in strength of record this season, according to ESPN's College Football Power Index.
- Be sure to check out USA TODAY Sports' new College Football Unfiltered podcast, hosted by USA TODAY Sports columnist Blake Toppmeyer.
- This person just went down to College Station in a tough one and squeaked out a win (against Texas A&M) Rodgers noted.
- While Texas hosts Arkansas at 3: 30 p.m, ET on Saturday.
- That debate continued on ESPN's "Get Up", where college football analyst Jordan Rodgers weighed in on the rankings.
Alabama over Texas? ESPN analyst blasts CFP committee's logic. John Leuzzi USA TODAY. Most overrated and underrated teams in latest CFP rankings.
Which teams did the CFP selection committee rank too high or too low? Our college football insiders break down the most overrated and underrated teams in the latest College Football Playoff rankings.
In practice, the third installment of the College Football Playoff rankings left plenty to discuss heading into the final two weeks of the regular season.
Among the biggest talking points was Alabama remaining at No. 3 in the selection committee's top 25 despite an uninspiring road win over Vanderbilt and losses by each of the Crimson Tide's previous opponents that the committee views as solid resume wins.
HAYES: CFP committee's Alabama obsession has turned its rankings into a farce.
That debate continued on ESPN's "Get Up", where college football analyst Jordan Rodgers weighed in on the rankings. Rodgers, a former Vanderbilt quarterback, took matter with the committee's apparent application of its conference-strength metric, arguing it was not being applied consistently throughout SEC teams.
"If you look at Alabama's best wins vs. Texas' best wins, it's not even close. And then to the same thing we just talked regarding, the committee giving props to Alabama for going to Vandy, winning a tough game, they looked terrible in the first half but they don't provide the same that same credit to Tennessee. This person just went down to College Station in a tough one and squeaked out a win (against Texas A&M)" Rodgers noted.
Notably, the conference strength through league games metric is something new that the selection committee continued to its evaluation process, something which ESPN's Heather Dinich produced note of on the network's CFP rankings release show on Tuesday.
To Rodger's point, Texas is just ahead of Alabama in strength of record this season, according to ESPN's College Football Power Index. The Longhorns – who hold ranked wins at home against Ohio State, Mississippi and Mississippi State and ranked wins on the road at Tennessee, Missouri and LSU – are fifth in strength of record compared to the Crimson Tide. This person have a pair of ranked road wins against Mississippi State and LSU and are sixth in strength of record.
That remarked, the Longhorns do have two losses to teams that were unranked at the time in Florida and Oklahoma. Alabama, meanwhile, lacks a true "bad loss" on its resume, with its only defeats coming against Georgia and Tennessee. The Crimson Tide additionally had an opportunity to beat the Bulldogs at the end, but a no-call defensive pass interference against Georgia ceased that.
In practice, the Crimson Tide's CFP seeding has been a weekly topic of discussion since the first rankings unveiling after Kalen DeBoer's squad debuted at No. 5, which was eight spots ahead of Tennessee. This person rolled past Alabama, 26-10, just a few weeks prior to the Nov. 3 rankings. Tennessee moved down from No. 8 to No. 9 in Tuesday's rankings despite winning at Texas A&M.
"I don't think they're applying the same metrics even within the conference. Forget the Major Ten and SEC. That's what leaves me puzzling. I think Texas should be ahead of Alabama, " Rodgers continued. "I've already said before that I think Tennessee should be above Alabama too."
Rodgers' ESPN colleague, Greg McElroy, additionally reacted to the Crimson Tide's rankings and pointed out the committee acknowledging the "hangover effect" in Alabama's resume for how it played in its loss at Tennessee after losing to Georgia the week prior and then how it played this past week at Vanderbilt after an "emotional win" at LSU two weeks ago.
Alabama's resume has dropped from where it was a week ago. Their strength of schedule is sixth. Their strength of record is sixth, and at present they sit No. 3, according to the College Football Playoff Committee, McElroy said on his Always College Football podcast. . They (CFP committee) remarked a few other things in this that I had never heard before. Relative offense, I'd never heard that term before. I additionally would assume that they are using the margin of victory, the committee referenced it. They had the second best margin of victory in SEC games. And the last one is the hangover effect.
"This is the first I've ever heard the committee acknowledging the challenges of playing an emotional game and then the after week having to play again. It's the first I've ever heard the committee address this, ever. They are taking that Tennessee loss (for Alabama) with a grain of salt. That is news to me. I have never heard that before. I'm just shocked the committee is willing to overlook certain aspects of a team's resume since of a challenging game they played the week before. That's unique and different and not something I necessarily subscribe to."
Alabama hosts Chattanooga at 2 p.m. While Texas hosts Arkansas at 3: 30 p.m, ET on Saturday. ET and Tennessee hosts LSU and Lane Kiffin on Rocky Top at 3: 30 p.m. ET.
In practice, the fourth CFP rankings release is set for 7: 30 p.m. ET on Tuesday, Nov. 24.
Be sure to check out USA TODAY Sports' new College Football Unfiltered podcast, hosted by USA TODAY Sports columnist Blake Toppmeyer. You can stream on YouTube or download via Apple podcasts and Spotify. Share your feedback to support improve our site!
Taken together, the developments around greg McElroy, Jordan Rodgers baffled by CFP committees SEC criteria point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.

