A new Nepal, an old neighbour – Balendra Shah's India test

ByAnbarasan Ethirajan Global Affairs Correspondent.

BusinessNews Info Wire6 min read
A new Nepal, an old neighbour - Balendra Shah's India test

ByAnbarasan Ethirajan Global Affairs Correspondent.

Article outline

  1. What happened
  2. The key numbers
  3. Background
  4. Why it matters
  5. Official response
  6. The bottom line

Key points

  • India and Nepal share close ethnic, cultural, religious and economic ties, with a largely open border stretching more than 1, 750km (1, 080 miles).
  • India has often been among the first countries to assist Nepal during major natural disasters, including the 2015 earthquake and the flash floods in August this year.
  • While thousands remain missing and unaccounted for, the disaster killed more than 1, 450 in the Himalayan nation.
  • Since Nepal abolished monarchy and became a democratic republic in 2008 three political parties dominated the governance.
  • India has approved projects to import up to 1, 200MW of electricity from Nepal and is looking to expand imports further.

Nepal Prime Minister Balendra Shah's visit to India has raised hopes of a reset, marking the first high-level engagement between leaders of Nepal's new political generation and its giant neighbour.

It is Shah's first bilateral visit since his Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) swept to power in March, six months after a Gen Z uprising against corruption and nepotism toppled K P Sharma Oli's administration.

In practice, the 36-year-old rapper-turned-politician arrives in Delhi on Sunday for a two-day visit, during which he will meet his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi and other senior authorities.

Notably, the discussions are anticipated to cover a broad range of problems, including economic and energy cooperation, the opening of new air corridors, and a reconstruction assistance package after the devastating flash floods that struck Nepal in August.

Wedged between India and China, Nepal is a strategic buffer and, analysts say, its stability has direct implications for India's security.

But over the decades the relationship has been strained by territorial disputes, allegations of political interference and resentment over what plenty of in Nepal see as the dominant 'Sizeable Brother' attitude of Delhi. Nevertheless, analysts see Shah's visit as an opportunity for a reset.

"The new Nepali leadership says they do not have the political baggage of the past and they want to focus on development, diplomacy and economic partnership, " Ranjit Rae, a former Indian ambassador to Nepal tells BBC.

"They seem to be more pragmatic, less ideological. I personally feel it's an optimistic moment, " he adds.

Delhi has maintained close contacts with all of them – the Communist Party of Nepal (CPN – UML), the Nepali Congress and the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist Centre).

Nepal's communist parties were seen as closer to India's rival China, owing to ideological ties, and often criticised Delhi over what they viewed as unequal bilateral agreements.

Due to Nepal's strategic location, both Delhi and Beijing compete for influence in Kathmandu, leading to accusations the two Asian giants are meddling in the internal affairs of Nepal. But Nepal's ties with India extend beyond diplomacy and strategic interests.

For context, the Hindu-majority nations share deep social ties, with families straddling the open border and communities interacting daily.

Bilateral trade exceeds $9bn, heavily skewed in India's favour – a longstanding source of resentment in Kathmandu. India is additionally Nepal's main supplier of petroleum products and a number of food items, and a key transit route for its trade with the rest of the world.

One key area of co-operation is hydropower. India has approved projects to import up to 1, 200MW of electricity from Nepal and is looking to expand imports further.

"India has a massive demand for electricity and Nepal has the potential to generate due to its water resources and geography. It's not just bilateral, Nepal additionally exports electricity to Bangladesh via India, " states Rae.

India has often been among the first countries to assist Nepal during major natural disasters, including the 2015 earthquake and the flash floods in August this year. Despite the close links, Nepal and India have their differences.

As part of its territory, in 2019, Nepal was furious after India published a map that included areas asserted by Kathmandu, in a western region close to the border with China. That raised heightened awareness in Kathmandu regarding the region.

Meanwhile, the diplomatic wrangle escalated after Nepal published its own map which included those disputed areas.

"I hope Nepal's prime minister raises the border matter with Delhi this time. There may not be a resolution immediately, but they should start negotiations to settle the matter, " Kanak Mani Dixit, a veteran Nepali political analyst, informed the BBC.

Nepal has additionally long called on India to open extra air entry routes, allowing substantial aircraft to fly in from the west to its new airports at Bhairahawa, near the Buddhist holy site of Lumbini, and Pokhara, a major tourist destination.

Access to Indian airspace would mean shorter flights at lower cost and, with more flights, the airports would become commercially viable.

Some in Nepal additionally believe that Delhi is wary of the fact that the Gautam Buddha international airport was constructed by China's Northwest Civil Aviation Airport and the airport in Pokhara was built with Chinese financial assistance.

Shah has yet to create any overtures to Beijing, but sent a 20-member delegation of party MPs to China for an 11-day visit from 15 November, ahead of his trip to India – seen as an effort to balance ties with Nepal's two powerful neighbours.

Shah had pledged not to travel abroad during his first year in office, but devastating flash floods in August have changed the calculus.

While international aid pledged so far has fallen short of expectations, his administration estimates reconstruction will cost almost $5bn.

But some observers in Nepal believe that Shah's preparations for the high-stake India visit have been less than thorough.

"Prime Minister Shah and his advisors are young and fresh, but they do lack experience. Repeatedly they have exhibited a lack of gravitas in governance. It would be essential for diplomacy with an overwhelmingly powerful neighbour, " notes Dixit.

Shah is already facing criticism over some of his government's recent decisions, including to remove police chief Dan Bahadur from his post after he allegedly refused to comply with directives from the Prime Minister's office.

Police were sent to some news organisations to detain journalists for their news coverage triggering accusations of curtailing press freedom.

While Kathmandu has ambitions in advancing its ties with India, the real test for Shah would be to return home with tangible outcomes. Securing concrete commitments from Delhi on financial aid would be seen as a diplomatic success and could support blunt growing domestic criticism.

For now, a new Nepal, an old neighbour – Balendra Shah' s India test remains the part of the story worth watching, and further updates are likely as more details are confirmed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *