Fifth Circuit upholds dismissal of lawsuit against Jackson over lead contamination allegations

Fifth Circuit upholds dismissal of.

Key points

• Job market rebounds as employers add 162, 000 jobs; the unemployment rate stayed at 4.1%.
• Telle, at present serving as Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works, is a graduate of Mississippi State University.
• "We are pleased that the Fifth Circuit upheld the dismissal of these claims, " Mayor of Jackson John Horhn (D) remarked.
• A majority for the en banc Fifth Circuit agreed with the City, ruling in Sterling v.
• "Plaintiffs point to no binding precedent, and we have found none, allowing recovery under § 1983 for misrepresentations by public officials, " the judge wrote.

Fifth Circuit upholds dismissal of lawsuit against Jackson over lead contamination allegations. By: Cass Rutledge – September 8, 2026.

"The Constitution does not provide redress for every governmental wrongdoing. Rather, the remedy for Plaintiffs' injuries lies in pursuing tort claims, electing representatives who will better manage the public-water system, and petitioning their representatives for other remedies, " the majority opinion stated.

Notably, the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit against the City of Jackson stemming from allegations of lead contamination in the city's water system.

Meanwhile, the lawsuit alleged that the City and its authorities violated residents' constitutional rights by allowing lead to enter the municipal water supply and by telling residents it was safe to drink.

Notably, a majority for the en banc Fifth Circuit agreed with the City, ruling in Sterling v. City of Jackson that the plaintiffs' allegations did not establish a constitutional violation under the 14th Amendment.

Writing for the majority, Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt remarked, "The Constitution does not provide redress for every governmental wrongdoing. Rather, the remedy for Plaintiffs' injuries lies in pursuing tort claims, electing representatives who will better manage the public-water system, and petitioning their representatives for other remedies."

Engelhardt further asserted that the majority discovered no deeply rooted history or tradition establishing a constitutional right to truthful information from office-holders during a public-health crisis.

Meanwhile, the majority additionally went on that like the cases filed in New York that addressed alleged misrepresentations by public authorities concerning the air quality in New York City after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, "We too decline to expand substantive due process to render public officials liable for statements made during an evolving public crisis."

While concurring with the majority in part and dissenting in part, Judge Catharina Haynes wrote, "At a minimum, Plaintiffs are entitled to discovery on their sufficiently plausible allegations that the City violated their constitutional rights, and the proper course is for this case to be remanded to the district court to allow such discovery to occur.", nevertheless.

Notably, the Fifth Circuit additionally affirmed that Jackson City office-holders named in the lawsuit are protected by qualified immunity, making them immune from the lawsuit's claims.

"We find no controlling authority nor robust consensus of persuasive authority that clearly establishes a right to lead-free drinking water and truthful information from public officials, " the majority stated.

According to The opinion, the federal administration and the Mississippi State Department of Health have taken steps to address Jackson's water system, including investigations, monitoring, and measures intended to reduce lead levels.

"We are pleased that the Fifth Circuit upheld the dismissal of these claims, " Mayor of Jackson John Horhn (D) remarked. "The City remains committed to the health, safety, and well-being of every Jackson resident." The full ruling is shown below. Regarding the Author(s).

Cass Rutledge is a law student at the University of Mississippi. A native of Madison, Mississippi, he now resides in Oxford with his wife, Julie. News Paul Wiseman, Associated Press September 4, 2026.

U.S. Job market rebounds as employers add 162, 000 jobs; the unemployment rate stayed at 4.1%.

Employers have been reluctant to let go of the staff they have, so most Americans enjoy unusual job security and unemployment is low. More From This Author. Education Cass Rutledge, Frank Corder September 4, 2026.

Former Ole Miss Chancellor Jones files amicus brief opposing Mississippi's anti-DEI law. News Cass Rutledge September 2, 2026. $10 million USDA grant supports expansion of Leland Medical Clinic. News Cass Rutledge August 27, 2026. Judge orders psych evaluation for accused Beth Israel arsonist. News Magnolia Tribune September 8, 2026. Magnolia Mornings: September 8, 2026. News Frank Corder September 4, 2026. President Trump names Adam Telle Acting Secretary of the Army.

Telle, at present serving as Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works, is a graduate of Mississippi State University. He previously served on the staff of former Mississippi U.S. Senator Thad Cochran. Sports Marisa Atkinson September 4, 2026. College football's 'Wild West' era raises questions for its future.

Ole Miss law symposium examines how TV funds, compensation and legal battles transformed the game. News Matthew Daly, Associated Press September 4, 2026.

EPA seeks more public comments as it struggles to devise water rule that limits scope on wetlands. News Jeremy Pittari September 4, 2026.

MDA, HUD update covenants for recipients of Hurricane Katrina Homeowner Assistance Program. News Jeremy Pittari September 4, 2026.

Mississippi receives approval for WorkFlex waiver, removing barriers to meet employer needs. Business Frank Corder September 3, 2026. Mississippi middle of the pack in State Tax Competitiveness Index. Business Frank Corder September 2, 2026. Gulf Ship investing $44 million to expand Gulfport shipyard. Business Frank Corder August 28, 2026. Ocean Aero creating 45 jobs with $4 million expansion in Gulfport. Culture Meredith Biesinger September 8, 2026. Elvis '56 Returns: Tupelo celebrates a historic homecoming. Culture Alistair Begg September 8, 2026. The Lord be with you. Culture Robert St. John September 7, 2026.

Opinion Roger Wicker September 8, 2026. U.S. Must remain vigilant. Opinion Mike Chaney September 3, 2026. Mississippians deserve more affordable health insurance options. Opinion Sid Salter September 2, 2026. For over 40 years, Mississippi workers have exceeded expectations at Raytheon.

Taken together, the developments around fifth Circuit upholds dismissal of lawsuit against Jackson over lead contamination allegations point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.