Alberta's decisive decision to stay in Canada gives Carney backing to take on Trump
ByLyse Doucet Chief international correspondent, Reporting fromOttawa, Canada.
ByLyse Doucet Chief international correspondent, Reporting fromOttawa, Canada.
Article outline
- What happened
- What comes next
- The key numbers
- Background
- Reaction
- The bottom line
Key points
- "Don't mess with Canada, " cautioned Thomas Lukaszuk, a former lawmaker whose Forever Canadian campaign was central in this referendum's outcome.
- "But what happens after Donald Trump is gone and Canada no longer has a single, bombastic target which drives Canadians to rally around the flag?" he asks.
- "Build Canada Strong" has been Carney's mantra ever since he first entered politics, a complete neophyte, at the start of last year.
- The Economist magazine decided to put Carney on their cover, on this week of weeks for Canada, with a perfect red maple leaf between his teeth.
- Carney, the former central banker who grew up in Alberta, is now Canada's builder-in-chief – at home, and beyond its borders.
"Vote like Canada depends on it, " Prime Minister Mark Carney declared to cheering crowds in Calgary last week on a stage emblazoned with bright red and white "Forever Canadian" banners.
As preliminary results show more than two-thirds of Alberta voters remarked they want to remain a part of Canada, it's a message that appears to have struck a chord with the electorate.
But the future of the federation does still rest on its richest province.
Alberta, with most of Canada's proven oil reserves and abundant gas and mineral wealth, is playing a pivotal role in Ottawa's drive to survive a punishing trade war with the US by diversifying trade, strengthening its economy, and forging new alliances on the other side of the world.
As shortly as the scale of the victory was clear: "They chose unity, to build together, and to take care of each other.", note the emphasis in his first statement after Monday's vote on separation in the province.
Albertans' overwhelming "yes" to stay in Canada gives him political bricks and mortar, too.
As the "yes" count for Canada kept tumbling in, Lukaszuk underlined that this vote "will send a particularly robust message to the rest of the world", addressing elated supporters in Edmonton, the provincial capital.
Everyone knows he's talking regarding the troublesome neighbour to the south – in particular its president. This person keeps threatening to turn Canada into the 51st US state.
For context, the same day Albertans were voting on their future in Canada, Trump sent his own signal north at a rally in Kansas ahead of next month's US midterm polls.
"I will let you keep ice hockey, and I will let you keep your 'O Canada' national anthem, " he promised before adding: "We're only kidding." For Canadians, it's no laughing matter.
In the run up to this referendum, Carney reiterated a warning he's often sounded that "there are some outside our borders who are working to break us, so they own us" – even if he didn't spell out who "they" is. He didn't have to.
And, in this defining time for the separatist camp, some in their ranks didn't hide their direction of travel. Some of their most prominent leaders admitted they travelled to Washington three times last year to meet US State Department authorities and outline what an independent Alberta could offer – including a feasible oil pipeline through the US to the Pacific.
But the rest of the world may take only passing notice of what was, for Canada, an historic vote sparking conversations and reservations nationwide, from coast to coast to coast.
"Short of a vote to separate, most foreign governments, with the exception of the United States, have little interest in domestic Canadian politics, " notes Professor Janice Stein, founding director of the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy at the University of Toronto.
"Foreign investors are focused on the time it will take to complete major infrastructure projects, a return on investment, and predictable regulations, " she explains in a nod to Carney's long list of megaprojects he hopes will eventually turbocharge economic expansion. They're all costly; plenty of will take years to build.
Meanwhile, an ambitious blueprint already includes a proposed pipeline to the Pacific coast which opens opportunities for Alberta's oil to reach Asian markets – a move which additionally addresses Alberta's long-standing grievance that its economy has been stifled by federal policies, including environmental regulations.
At a rally in Alberta last week, it was Carney's comment that the pipeline "will reduce our dependence on the United States" that triggered the loudest and longest applause of the night.
After Monday's vote, Carney – the former UN Special Envoy for Climate Action and Finance – pointed to "unleashing our full potential as a global energy superpower with Alberta as its core". Political and economic pressures now seem to eclipse his green credentials.
'Great result for Canada', notes Carney as Alberta votes to reject separatism. Massive setback for Alberta's separatist movement after decisive defeat.
At home there are feasible wide-reaching repercussions from the final tallies in the referendum's nine other questions which dealt with matters ranging from greater provincial powers, the costs of immigration, and potential constitutional changes.
Those results are certain to provoke debate, and accord making or breaking, involving Canada's nine other provinces and three territories. They all have their own grievances, too.
Notably, the prime minister has had to defend himself when journalists ask if he is spending too much time on foreign trips with his charm offensive to build new political alliances and trade partnerships, including an unprecedented and still uncertain offer of associate membership of the European Union.
"I can do both and I need to do both, " he lately replied with his signature bluntness before listing the more than 16 bills which went through Parliament in the last session dealing with everything from major tax changes, public safety, and the rate of fuel.
For now, Carney is riding high in the polls at home – including in Alberta. It doesn't traditionally backing his Liberal party – in a long "political honeymoon" other beleaguered politicians would envy.
And the plain-speaking politician's solid and steady response to Trump threats, including retaliatory tariffs, has seen his star rising on the world stage. It's an unexpected turn for a country which has often been missing from top tables and has sometimes even been dismissed as "boring".
Meanwhile, the Economist magazine decided to put Carney on their cover, on this week of weeks for Canada, with a perfect red maple leaf between his teeth.
"Mark Carney shows middle powers how to handle a dangerous world, " reads one of its headlines, with an article which additionally focuses on Canada's "vulnerabilities" including Alberta's ballot.
"The broader takeaway from this vote might be that Canadian unity is in fine shape, " remarks David Moscrop, political scientist and author of the forthcoming book On Nationalism.
Carney's decision to lately walk away from trade negotiations with the US offered rise to another swell of Canadian pride and patriotism. But if this trade war drags on with a country which traditionally takes 70% of Canada's exports, Canadians will feel even greater pain in their daily lives.
But today is a day to vigorously wave the maple leaf flag.
"It's a win for Team Canada and its resilience, " commented CBC journalist Janyce McGregor during the public broadcaster's rolling coverage of a vast country of never-ending building problems.
Taken together, the developments around alberta' s decisive decision to stay in Canada gives Carney backing to take point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.




