Why are Bukele’s Salvadoran troops in Haiti and what have they achieved?

Meanwhile, the streets of Haiti's capital, Port-au-Prince, rang out on Tuesday and Wednesday with chants from local residents in backing of a president who was not their own: El Salvador's Nayib Bukele.

OpinionNews Info Wire7 min read
Haitians protest in support of El Salvador’s anti-gang troop deployment

Meanwhile, the streets of Haiti's capital, Port-au-Prince, rang out on Tuesday and Wednesday with chants from local residents in backing of a president who was not their own: El Salvador's Nayib Bukele.

Article outline

  1. What happened
  2. Background
  3. The key numbers
  4. Official response
  5. What comes next
  6. The bottom line

Key points

  • Since 2022, according to Reuters, more than 22, 000 individuals have been killed in gang-related violence, including security operations.
  • When it had just surpassed 2, 000 personnel, the Salvadoran deployment already outnumbers the GSF, according to numbers from the GSF's special representative Jack Christofides, on October 18.
  • Thousands turned out to cheer on the roughly 2, 500 soldiers Bukele has sent since October.
  • The force was created to support Haitian authorities agreement with a security crisis that has grown more severe since the 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moise.
  • Shortly after the technicians went missing, Bukele confirmed a new military operation in Haiti, sending 100 special forces soldiers to rescue them.

Thousands turned out to cheer on the roughly 2, 500 soldiers Bukele has sent since October. What began as a narrow mission to rescue four missing Salvadoran aviation technicians has grown into a much broader military operation.

For some of those who marched, the intervention is exactly what the country needs after years of kidnappings, killings, and displacement, with little sign of relief.

But even with the Haitian government's backing and a warm reception from the public, questions are growing regarding what the troops are doing on the ground and what kind of mark Bukele will ultimately leave on Haiti. Why are Salvadoran troops in Haiti?

When four Salvadoran aviation technicians working with the United Nations-backed Gang Suppression Force (GSF) went missing after armed men attacked their vehicle near Port-au-Prince, the immediate trigger came on October 18.

In practice, the force was created to support Haitian authorities agreement with a security crisis that has grown more severe since the 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moise. According to Reuters, gangs now control more than 80 percent of the capital region, with Haitian and international forces struggling to reclaim that territory.

Shortly after the technicians went missing, Bukele confirmed a new military operation in Haiti, sending 100 special forces soldiers to rescue them. Since then, he's sent regarding 2, 500 in total.

Most of them are operating outside the UN-backed force and outside the UN backing office's monitoring mechanisms, according to UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric.

And the deployment itself has turned from a narrow rescue operation to a broader offensive against Haiti's gangs, with Salvadoran soldiers joining Haitian security forces, the GSF, and private contractors, including Blackwater founder Erik Prince's Vectus Global.

Bukele, who gained international notoriety for a crackdown on gangs in El Salvador that led to a sharp decline in crime but has drawn widespread condemnation over human rights abuses, has been aggressively promoting the deployment on social media.

He has posted dramatic videos of helicopter attacks on gang leaders' properties and, more lately, footage of rallies cheering on his troops.

"I never expected anything like this, " he wrote in a Tuesday post accompanying a video of a rally. "I hear you loud and clear. I love you, too."

Neither the Haitian administration nor the Salvadoran administration replied to Al Jazeera's requests for comment regarding the troops in Haiti. Why are some Haitians cheering on the Salvadoran troops?

For context, the troops have landed against the backdrop of a worsening humanitarian crisis in Haiti, with almost 1.5 million individuals displaced from their homes, and violence making it challenging to access food and basic services. Since 2022, according to Reuters, more than 22, 000 individuals have been killed in gang-related violence, including security operations.

At rallies in Port-au-Prince and other parts of Haiti, demonstrators voiced backing for the deployment. Some who spoke to The Associated Press news agency described losing loved ones to gang violence and being forced to leave their homes.

"The support we see from many Haitians comes from sheer desperation after years of failure and widespread terror, " Louimann Maceus, president of the human rights organisation Ensemble des Citoyens Competents a la Recherche de l'Egalite des Droits de l'Homme en Haiti (ECCREDHH), informed Al Jazeera. "People are exhausted."

"There is a genuine hope, especially among the hundreds of thousands of internally displaced people we work with who just want to return safely home, " remarked Maceus, who lives in Port-au-Prince.

That hope, he remarked, follows years of frustration with UN-backed forces. It he stated had done little to improve security.

International Crisis Group analyst Diego Da Rin additionally links some of the enthusiasm to what he describes as a really effective communication campaign by Bukele, whose videos of strikes on gang leaders' homes are all over Haitian social media.

"These are symbolic wins that everybody was waiting for, " he remarked, adding that AI-generated videos were additionally circulating of gang leaders being arrested.

But backing for the deployment is not universal. Da Rin pointed to the residents of gang-controlled areas.

"Many of these people, who clearly see the risks in these iron-fist operations, are extremely scared of being attacked and being collateral damage of any of these operations, " remarked Da Rin. What have Salvadoran troops actually achieved?

Security force clashes and drone strikes targeting gangs rose by 46 percent in the 21 days after the start of the deployment, compared to the 21 days before it, according to the conflict monitoring group the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED).

ACLED estimated more than 100 individuals were killed in the same period, including at least 26 civilians.

Haiti's Justice Minister Patrick Pelissier, nevertheless, stated on Monday that the administration had received no reports of civilian casualties in the latest operations. It it described as professional, according to Reuters.

Bukele has applied social media to highlight what he sees as the offensive's successes.

As residents ran away from the area, after Salvadoran troops joined Haitian police and a administration task force in a November 8 attack on a house belonging to Wilson Joseph, leader of the powerful 400 Mawozo gang, Bukele posted video of helicopters repeatedly firing at the building. Joseph reportedly was not there and survived the attack.

Notably, a few days afterwards, Haitian national police and Bukele unveiled that they'd retaken control of the national football stadium. Although it's unclear how exactly they were applied in the operation, bukele shared video of robot dogs armed with rifles moving through the corridors of the stadium alongside troops.

Da Rin remarked it was worth noting that police initially credited their officers and the task force with retaking the stadium before handing control over to Salvadoran troops. This person set up a base there.

For context, the stadium is a useful spot to launch operations against nearby gang strongholds, he continued, but it represented a relatively small gain from positions Haitian forces had already secured.

On Wednesday, Bukele posted another video showing a helicopter attack on the home of Jeff Larose, leader of the Taliban gang. It controls the area of Canaan in northern Port-au-Prince.

It was not clear whether the attack had killed Larose or whether Haiti's police or army had participated. The GSF was not involved, according to The Associated Press.

For displaced individuals looking to return home, the gains have yet to produce a tangible difference, noted Da Rin.

After the attack on Joseph's house, none of the security forces set up a permanent presence in the area, he remarked.

"Armed groups were able to return and are now intimidating residents, searching their phones, threatening people suspected of sharing information with the security forces, " Da Rin informed Al Jazeera.

He cautioned that forces appeared to be "in a race" to show results without a unified strategy to sustain them.

Salvadoran authorities have stated they plan to leave once the missing technicians are discovered. Joseph, leader of the 400 Mawozo gang, informed the Associated Press earlier this month that they were dead, but their fate remains officially unknown.

"The priority should be to plan the most difficult part, how the forces will work together to establish lasting control, " remarked Da Rin. Why are some experts concerned regarding the deployment? The terms of the Salvadoran deployment haven't been created public.

Amnesty International has called on both governments to explain who oversees the troops, what rules govern their employ of force, and how civilians can safely report abuses.

For now, why are Bukele's Salvadoran troops in Haiti and what have they achieved? Remains the part of the story worth watching, and further updates are likely as more details are confirmed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *