Clancy mistrial distracts from moms who actually deserve empathy | Opinion
Clancy mistrial distracts from moms who actually deserve empathy Opinion Lindsay Clancy killed her children and received a mistrial and a wave of backing.
Clancy mistrial distracts from moms who actually deserve empathy Opinion Lindsay Clancy killed her children and received a mistrial and a wave of backing.
Article outline
- What happened
- Why it matters
- Background
- The key numbers
- The bottom line
Key points
- Lenore Skenazy, founder of the Free-Range Kids movement, lately detailed the case in Reason.
- Police were then called, and Child Protective Services additionally demonstrated up and investigated Parkinson for abuse and neglect.
- Unlike the rest of the country, I have tried to stay away from the nonstop drama and news coverage after the Lindsay Clancy murder trial.
- As my colleague Nicole Russell has detailed, something that shocked me throughout this trial was all the women who spoke in defense of Clancy.
- If there's a mom to feel empathy for, I would suggest you look to Karyann Parkinson of Virginia.
In practice, a hung jury led to a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case. The trial has reignited the debate over postpartum mental health and criminal responsibility.
Every time I see Clancy's face, all I can think regarding is her taking each of her three innocent children – one by one – and strangling the life out of them in the family's basement. It makes me sick.
This trial wasn't regarding whether she committed these heinous acts – it's whether she should be held criminally responsible. After days of deliberation, a deadlocked jury forced the judge on Sept. 4 to declare a mistrial. That would probable mean a new trial.
Judge William Sullivan offered Clancy's defense attorney an hour for a last-ditch appeal to remove the one holdout juror out of 12 who refused to acquit Clancy for her actions.
Clancy's defense has argued she isn't criminally responsible since she was suffering from "postpartum psychosis" (the insanity defense) when she murdered her children. Prosecutors argued Clancy acted "intentionally, rationally, and swiftly" to kill her children. And one juror appears to have agreed.
Lindsay Clancy case concluded in mistrial. What would have been the right verdict? Tell us. Opinion Forum. Justice for Lindsay Clancy's children is all that matters.
I'm not going to try to play armchair detective or attorney in this case.
All I care regarding is that justice prevails for the three young children who lost their lives at the hands of their mother.
As my colleague Nicole Russell has detailed, something that shocked me throughout this trial was all the women who spoke in defense of Clancy. Plenty of of them maintained they identified with Clancy's disgusting actions.
Whether Clancy was in her right mind or not, she murdered her babies. It's with them that my sympathies lie. Lindsay Clancy killed her kids. Why are women defending her? Opinion.
Hopefully, prosecutors learned from this trial and will modify their approach in a subsequent one. Since Clancy needs to pay for what she did, and she doesn't deserve the adoring fans she's amassed.
For instance, they've been showing in droves outside the courtroom, wearing pink in Clancy's "honor." I'm not sure what exactly that notes concerning our society, but it's nothing good. Here's a mom who actually deserves our sympathy.
In practice, the mother of five was convicted lately of "the delinquency of a minor" – the child is her own. It's a first-degree misdemeanor and comes with a six-month jail sentence. The judge suspended the sentence, pending good behavior, but the conviction remains.
Her crime? She allowed her 5-year-old son to go for a walk by himself in their gated community.
Someone saw the child walking and alerted security. Police were then called, and Child Protective Services additionally demonstrated up and investigated Parkinson for abuse and neglect. They have since placed her on the state's child abuse and neglect registry.
This is a mother who seems to love her family and was simply giving her son a little taste of independence. She didn't harm him in any way.
If Clancy, who killed her children, could attract sympathetic women and moms to stand for her, I would like to think this mom could additionally garner an army of women to defend her. Yet I doubt she will.
Ingrid Jacques is a columnist at USA TODAY. Contact her at [email protected] or on X: @Ingrid_Jacques. SMS Facebook Twitter Email. Share your feedback to support improve our site! Share your feedback to support improve our site!
Taken together, the developments around clancy mistrial distracts from moms who actually deserve empathy point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.




