‘Zero transparency’: Inside Trump’s plans for Venezuela’s oil money
Meanwhile, the administration of United States President Donald Trump is facing criticism over how it has handled billions of dollars in oil revenue collected from Venezuela.
Meanwhile, the administration of United States President Donald Trump is facing criticism over how it has handled billions of dollars in oil revenue collected from Venezuela.
Article outline
- What happened
- Official response
- The key numbers
- What comes next
- Why it matters
- The bottom line
Key points
- When Trump authorised a military operation to abduct Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, tensions between the US and Venezuela reached a tipping point on January 3.
- Under the terms of the agreement, the US gained "majority control" in a 100-year accord for 17 Venezuelan oilfields, with proven reserves of 65 billion barrels.
- North American Blue Energy Partners (NABEP), a firm owned by Venezuelan businessman Alejandro Betancourt, was given the rights to operate the fields.
- Since January 3, Trump's administration has controlled Venezuela's oil exports, gathering the revenue in an account overseen exclusively by the US Treasury.
- "American sweat, ingenuity and toil created the oil industry in Venezuela, " White House aide Stephen Miller remarked at the time.
Last week, the Department of State published a 53-page report aimed at shedding light on the account's activities. It made public that at least $12.11bn have passed through the account since the start of the year.
But critics say the report lacks key details regarding where the capital came from and who it is going to.
"There's been zero transparency on all of the financial engineering associated with how $12bn of Venezuelan oil was changing hands and being utilised, " remarked Tyson Slocum, the director of the energy programme at Public Citizen, a US-based consumer advocacy nonprofit.
"All we have now is a very barebones narrative of how the funds were used, but not details on what entities were involved."
When his administration began seizing oil tankers leaving the South American country, reservations concerning Trump's intends for Venezuela's oil sector began late last year.
Any oil on board, Trump remarked, would be kept or sold by the US. He and members of his administration framed the confiscated fuel as compensation for the losses incurred when Venezuela nationalised its oil industry decades ago.
"American sweat, ingenuity and toil created the oil industry in Venezuela, " White House aide Stephen Miller remarked at the time. "Its tyrannical expropriation was the largest recorded theft of American wealth and property."
In a speech that morning, Trump highlighted the role oil had played in his decision. "We're going to be taking out a tremendous amount of wealth out of the ground, " Trump remarked.
He proceeded to explain that some of the Venezuelan oil proceeds would go "to the United States of America in the form of reimbursement for the damages caused us by that country".
Days afterwards, Trump disclosed he had spoken to oil firms "before and after" the operation. He additionally held a gathering with oil industry executives at the White House to discuss intends for Venezuela.
Legal experts have triggered concern that the January 3 operation was an attack on Venezuela's sovereignty, in violation of international law.
They have additionally questioned the legality of seizing another country's natural resources, given that a 1962 United Nations resolution grants nations "permanent sovereignty" over their own natural resources.
But supporters of Trump's actions have pointed to Maduro's history of violent repression and anti-democratic actions in Venezuela as justification for the operation.
Maduro has since been replaced by his former vice president, Delcy Rodriguez. This person has largely cooperated with Trump's demands.
But the focus on Venezuela's oil revenue has left some critics questioning whether Trump intends to address the human rights matters in the South American country.
Trump has repeatedly downplayed the importance of democratic elections in Venezuela, remarked John Feeley, a former US ambassador and senior diplomat in Latin America.
"Trump has made patently clear that he has no interest in the democratic future of Venezuela, " remarked Feeley, calling the US-Venezuela relationship "protectorate neocolonialism". 'The biggest oil accord in history'.
More recent manoeuvres have additionally raised speculation concerning the Trump administration's commitment to transparency in its management of Venezuelan oil.
In late August, for instance, Trump confirmed his administration would have a direct stake in extracting almost a fifth of Venezuela's oil.
In practice, the Pentagon, meanwhile, took a 35 percent stake in the firm, and the US was guaranteed 20 percent of the oil output at cost. Trump called it "the biggest oil deal in history".
But Betancourt has faced investigations in the US, Spain and Switzerland over accusations of funds laundering.
After this article was published, a spokesperson for NABEP reached out to Al Jazeera with a statement that Betancourt "has never been charged with a crime in any country and denies wrongdoing".
Venezuelan opposition leader Maria Corina Machado, nevertheless, stated the contract with NABEP "evidently does not reflect the levels of transparency that Venezuelan society wants".
Venezuela has long struggled to export its oil, so the fact that it will now be sold on the open market is beneficial to the country's economy, remarked Luis A Pacheco, a former executive with Venezuela's state oil business and nonresident fellow at the Baker Institute Center for Energy Studies at Rice University. But Pacheco is sceptical of Trump's accord with NABEP.
"This is an obscure outfit with no known financial sources, with very little tech wherewithal, " he remarked. "This so-called mega-deal, without doubt, will certainly yield very little of what's expected of it." Little transparency over billions of dollars.
In practice, the shroud of secrecy surrounding the Venezuelan oil deals has spurred some Democrats in the US Congress to press for greater accountability.
In September, Democrats in the House of Representatives (PDF) and Senate asked the administration to disclose what had been uncovered by KPMG, an outside accounting firm hired to audit transactions involving Venezuelan oil exports.
In practice, the State Department did matter its report last week. But key portions were redacted, including who deposited funds into the accounts and who the final recipients of the funds were.
Feeley, the diplomat, remarked there are additionally questions regarding the total sum of the proceeds. Only $12bn is accounted for in the report.
"We have no idea how that money was used, and we have no idea what percent of the total amount of money deposited in the US Treasury that $12bn represents, " remarked Feeley. "But most experts allege that it is only a fraction."
In an official note to Al Jazeera, a State Department spokesperson remarked its report "provides a comprehensive account, down to the cent, of the Venezuelan natural resource revenues deposited in, held by, and disbursed" from the account.
Venezuela's requests for disbursement are checked against a "list of approved and prohibited expenditure categories", the spokesperson continued.
For context, the funds are then applied for "essential public services, macroeconomic stability, and the rebuilding of key sectors such as energy, healthcare and infrastructure".
But who receives those funds remains unclear. Pacheco remarked there is no reason the US could not disclose details of the monetary flow.
"Even though this report gives you some information, it still doesn't give you light into the most important thing, which is what is the Venezuelan regime is doing with the money, " Pacheco remarked.
Taken together, the developments around 'Zero transparency': Inside Trump's plans for Venezuela's oil money point to a situation that is still moving, and the coming days should bring more clarity.

