Punjab stand on judge sets disturbing precedent
Opinion Punjab stand on judge sets disturbing precedent Governments at the Centre and in the states can disagree with each other.
Opinion Punjab stand on judge sets disturbing precedent Governments at the Centre and in the states can disagree with each other.
Article outline
- What happened
- Official response
- The key numbers
- The bottom line
Key points
- 3 min readSep 9, 2026 06: 05 AM IST First published on: Sep 9, 2026 at 06: 05 AM IST.
- The Supreme Court Collegium recommended Justice Mishra and three other judges for appointment as chief justices of four high courts on August 6.
- © The Indian Express Pvt Ltd. # Punjab and Haryana High Court.
- Punjab notes that the Centre breached the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) that governs the appointment of judges.
- Treating adverse orders as a personal affront cannot become a template for political parties.
Punjab notes that the Centre breached the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) that governs the appointment of judges. It requires the Centre to consult states before high court appointments.
Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra took oath as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court on Monday, with an empty chair in the front row, reserved for Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann. A day earlier, in an unusual step, the Punjab Cabinet met and asked Governor Gulab Chand Kataria to hold off the oath-taking, arguing that the Centre had notified the appointment without the state's consent. Punjab notes that the Centre breached the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) that governs the appointment of judges. It requires the Centre to consult states before high court appointments. But that is not the end of this story.
Notably, the Supreme Court Collegium recommended Justice Mishra and three other judges for appointment as chief justices of four high courts on August 6. The delay in Punjab's response held up all four chief justice appointments. The Centre notified the appointment on September 5. Punjab is right to point out that the MoP fixes no deadline for a state's response. But that flexibility is since judicial appointments are a consultative process. If the Mann administration had reservations concerning Justice Mishra, it had weeks to put them on file, where they could be examined. It doesn't support Punjab's case that Justice Mishra's court has lately been an uncomfortable place for the state administration. As Acting Chief Justice, his bench pulled up Punjab in August for withholding dearness allowance dues even as it discovered ample capital for advertising. His court additionally heard a Mohali case in which allegations were produced against the Chief Minister's wife. It the AAP has described as politically motivated.
Earlier in Delhi, the AAP sought to have Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma taken off the appeal in the excise policy case in which party leaders are arraigned as accused. Treating adverse orders as a personal affront cannot become a template for political parties. Certainly, there is a case for bringing defined timelines into the MoP. The SC has set the Centre a benchmark for names reiterated by the Collegium – they must be cleared within three to four weeks. Notably, a comparable window for state responses – after which consent is deemed given – would remove the ambiguity this episode exposed. Governments at the Centre and in the states can disagree with each other. What none of them is entitled to do is to let political bickering hijack judicial appointments.
In short, punjab stand on judge sets disturbing precedent is the central thread here, and readers can expect follow-up reporting as the picture becomes clearer.




