Who holds the leash?
Who holds the leash? Who holds the leash?
Who holds the leash? Who holds the leash?
Article outline
- What happened
- The key numbers
- Official response
- What comes next
- Reaction
- The bottom line
Key points
- Wingate ruled Thursday, June 1, 2023, that the Mississippi chief justice cannot be a defendant in a lawsuit that challenges a state law dealing with appointed judges.
- No history of the United States is complete without the Battle of Vicksburg and its impact on the outcome of the Civil War, writes Senator Roger Wicker.
- Scholars at Harvard's Berkman Klein Center think that's a good rule for artificial intelligence.
- Earlier this year, regarding 4, 000 properties were getting water without being billed or metered.
- The Fifth Circuit Court took the case away from the judge on appeal – a step it remarked was extraordinary and rarely invoked.
Who holds the leash? Who holds the leash? By: Kelley Williams – November 10, 2026.
U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate smiles on Aug. 19, 2022, in Jackson, Miss. Wingate ruled Thursday, June 1, 2023, that the Mississippi chief justice cannot be a defendant in a lawsuit that challenges a state law dealing with appointed judges. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis, File).
AI does not sign the orders. The Judge does. In Jackson, that means he signs off on the water bill, too.
Notably, a thousand years ago, English law had a plain rule for dogs. If your dog bit someone, you answered for it.
Scholars at Harvard's Berkman Klein Center think that's a good rule for artificial intelligence. The Harvard Gazette lays out their idea under the headline "Is that bot a Pomeranian or a wolf – and who to sue when it 'bites?"
They sort AI by two questions. How dangerous is it? And is there an owner who can be held to account? A low-risk chatbot with a clear owner is a Pomeranian. In practice, a high-stakes system still under human control is a pit bull. Pit bulls are allowed. But somebody holds the leash, and somebody pays when it bites.
In Jackson, we just had a dog bite. And the judge who was not holding the leash is the same man who runs our water. The dog bite: On July 20, 2025, U.S. District Judge Henry T. Wingate blocked Mississippi's new law on DEI programs in public schools. His order named plaintiffs who were not in the case. It named defendants nobody had sued. It relied on declarations from four individuals who do not appear in the record. It quoted words the statute does not contain.
When the Attorney General flagged the errors, the judge did not explain. He pulled the order off the public docket, posted a backdated "corrected" version, and called the mistakes "clerical." Only after Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley demanded answers did the truth come out. As a "foundational drafting assistant." According to the Judge himself it: "should have never been docketed.", the Judge's law clerk applied an AI program, Perplexity.
For context, the Fifth Circuit Court took the case away from the judge on appeal – a step it remarked was extraordinary and rarely invoked. It called the proceedings "a botch job, to say the least." It discovered that even the corrected order cited "an apparent AI hallucination." Fifth Circuit Judge Jerry Smith wrote "This district judge carelessly exercised his Article III power by issuing sloppy edicts based on falsehoods and fabrications."
He continued, "The District Court – or perhaps being charitable, its AI agent – ignored and manipulated governing law apparently to satisfy a policy agenda." Under Harvard's rule, the responsibility is his. The dog did not sign the order. It's owner, the Judge, did.
In practice, the same Judge runs our water system. Since 2022, he has been, in effect, the board of directors and CEO of Jackson's water system. Has he run it to satisfy a policy agenda too? He appointed Ted Henifin as the federal manager. Henifin runs the systems through JXN Water. Henifin answers only to the Judge. No mayor. No council. No Public Service Commission. No voters.
For context, the results are mixed at best. In February, the Judge approved a 12 percent rate growth and called the City's opposition "fiscal fantasy." JXN Water now states it needs 10 percent more in 2027, 9 percent in 2028, and 8 percent in 2029. Earlier this year, regarding 4, 000 properties were getting water without being billed or metered. A "Water Availability Charge" based on meter size seems more like a property tax than a water bill. It hits the more than one in four Jackson residents who live in poverty especially hard.
Who will run the water system when the receivership ends? Henifin's new plan would create an authority whose first board is appointed by the Judge. Federal oversight could run to December 2029. Same song third verse.
For context, the Judge has already partly blocked the MS Legislature's own water authority, and the State has appealed. The state environmental agency notes it first saw the plan's alternatives on Oct. 5 and has asked for 30 more days. The mayor wants a hearing. Probably the City Council too.
To be fair, the Judge has not rubber-stamped everything. He held a dozen hearings on rates. Was his decision based on what he learned from the hearings – or on a policy agenda? And to be fair he didn't volunteer for the job. He didn't seem to be in a hurry to finish it though. The receivership exists since our own Jackson leaders let the system collapse. Enough blame to go around.
But look at the structure of the cure. One judge, appointed for life, is regulator, referee, and boss of the utility meanwhile. Who controls him? Who holds his.
Leash? Has he applied AI carelessly to run the city's water system too.
Notably, the Harvard piece is blunt regarding owners. With a clear owner, it notes, the "companies or government agencies behind them remain legally responsible for fixing mistakes and compensating anyone harmed." The Judge's court is a administration agency. Jackson ratepayers are the dog bite victims.
AI is becoming ubiquitous. It's useful, but additionally fallible. I'm learning to employ it. Sometimes it fetches the wrong thing. Sometimes it runs off with the bumper. Sometimes it chases an imaginary rabbit. Sometimes it dances with wolves. It bears watching and caution when using as an agent. These are not reasons not to employ it. These are reasons to hold the leash. So here are some questions.
Has AI been applied to draft any order or analyze any matters in the Jackson water case? If so, has this been disclosed?
Have mistakes, if any, been corrected on the record? Not erased and not backdated?
Dogs have collars with their owners' names – in case the dog gets lost. Additionally useful if the dog bites someone. The Harvard article suggests a digital dog tag for AI pit bulls.
I'm not a pit bull. But I put a digital dog tag on this column. Regarding the Author(s).
Kelley Williams is a member of Bigger Pie Forum. The mission of Bigger Pie Forum is to research and share educational information that fosters greater economic freedom and individual responsibility. The Forum serves as a voice of free-market encouragement in Mississippi with the goal of stimulating private sector expansion for a bigger and brighter Mississippi. Opinion Russ Latino November 2, 2026. If Republicans stay home Tuesday, Mississippi's Senate race could obtain interesting.
Mississippi hasn't elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since 1982. That's a long time, and it speaks to the considerable structural advantages Republicans enjoy. But those advantages aren't self-executing. They depend on actual human beings getting off their couches and casting ballots. More From This Author. Opinion Kelley Williams July 13, 2026. Black Swans and Mudberg. Opinion Kelley Williams June 8, 2026. What the Corps understands but you don't. Opinion Kelley Williams June 1, 2026. Blissful ignorance vs. Mistakes of omission. Opinion Leah Long November 9, 2026. Shop small this holiday season and offer back to your community.
Opinion Roger Wicker October 30, 2026. Honoring Mississippi's role in American history.
No history of the United States is complete without the Battle of Vicksburg and its impact on the outcome of the Civil War, writes Senator Roger Wicker. Opinion Sid Salter October 28, 2026.
'Hail, Dear Old' State!' meant something quite special to the late Dr. Richard E. Holmes.
Holmes, MSU's first African American student, died Oct. 16 at age 82. News Frank Corder November 10, 2026. Butler to sit for nomination hearing in Senate Judiciary. News Christopher Rugaber, Associated Press November 10, 2026. Inflation ran hotter than projected last month, underscoring affordability challenges. News Magnolia Tribune November 10, 2026. Magnolia Mornings: November 10, 2026. Business Cass Rutledge November 10, 2026. Universal Services expanding operations in Leakesville. Business Frank Corder November 10, 2026. Ingalls, SUPSHIP break ground on new $50 million facility in Pascagoula. Business Cass Rutledge November 9, 2026.
Jabil is hiring more than 300 in Byhalia. Culture Meredith Biesinger November 10, 2026. Margaret's Grocery: The castle that love built. Culture Alistair Begg November 10, 2026. Culture Eddie Pells, Associated Press November 9, 2026.
College Football Playoff doubles up, expands to 24 teams beginning next season. Opinion Russ Latino November 4, 2026.
Democrats took Republicans behind the woodshed. The GOP has only itself to blame. Opinion Sid Salter November 4, 2026.
Like other tax proposals, California voters on Nov. 3 test-drove a tax on billionaires. Opinion Russ Latino November 3, 2026. A time for choosing: America's future is bigger than one election.
In short, who holds the leash? Is the central thread here, and readers can expect follow-up reporting as the picture becomes clearer.




